Refining Problem Statements Based on Research

As you have progressed through this course, you've learned the importance of crafting a clear and well-structured problem statement. Now, it's time to take your problem statement to the next level by incorporating research findings and valuable insights.

Evaluating Existing Research

To begin, you'll explore how to evaluate existing research relevant to your chosen problem. By reviewing what others have discovered, you can gain a deeper understanding of the problem's nuances, its historical context, and potential solutions that have been explored.

📺 Watch the following video lecture on evaluating research. (click link below to watch the video)

Lecture 15: Evaluating Research Articles

From the video, we learned that research articles are valuable sources of information. The information in these articles can help you better understand and articulate your problem of interest. You can find good research articles from a number of sources:

Academic Libraries: Most colleges and universities have extensive databases of scholarly journals and research articles. Check your institution's library website for resources.
Online Databases: Consider using databases like PubMed, ScienceDirect, and Google Scholar for comprehensive searches.
Open Access Publishers: Platforms like Plus PLoS offer a wide range of open-access research articles.

Websites are also common sources of information. However, not all websites are reliable. Use these criteria to evaluate websites:

Recency: Is the website up-to-date?
Relevance: Does the website relate to your topic?
Authority: Who authored the page, and are they affiliated with reputable institutions?
Accuracy: Can the information be verified and independently reviewed?
Purpose: What is the website's intended purpose, and are there any biases or advertisements?

So what happens after you find an article that is relevant to your problem of interest?

The next thing is to read it effectively by following these steps:

Start General: Begin by reading the title, abstract, and headings to get an overview of the article.
Skim Introduction and Conclusion: Review the introduction and conclusion to understand the big picture.
Define Unfamiliar Terms: Look up any unfamiliar terms to ensure comprehension.
Examine Tables and Figures: Pay attention to tables and figures as they help you understand the collected data.
Analyze Methods and Results: Focus on variables measured, hypotheses, and study findings.
Read Again: Reading the article multiple times can help you absorb all the information effectively.

📺 Watch the following videos on conducting a thorough literature review.

A literature review is essentially a comprehensive summary and analysis of existing research on a particular topic. In your context, a good literature review can serve 3 important functions:

Identifying existing knowledge about the problem: They help you discover what is already known about your chosen topic. This is crucial as it prevents you from duplicating research that has already been conducted.
Providing critical insights: Literature reviews offer a critical evaluation of existing research related to the problem. By examining methodologies, findings, and arguments, they allow you to assess the quality and validity of previous studies.
Identifying Gaps in Knowledge: One of the key benefits of a literature review is pinpointing gaps in current knowledge. This provides an opportunity for you to contribute something original to your field of study.

Here are the steps involved in conducting a literature review:

Step 1: Search for relevant literature on your topic in this case the problem of interest

Step 2: Evaluate and select sources

Step 3: Identify themes, debates, and gaps. As you read through your selected sources, it's crucial to take notes and identify the following elements:

Trends and patterns in theory, methodology, or results.
Key themes addressed across various sources.
Debates or contradictions among different studies.
Influential studies that have shaped the field.
Gaps or areas where further research is needed.

Step 4: Outline your literature review's structure. The structure of your literature review can vary depending on what you discover during your research and your specific objectives. There are four common approaches used to organize the literature:

Chronological: Organize sources from older to more recent publications.
Thematic: Group sources based on key themes or topics.
Methodological: Compare and contrast research methods used in different studies.
Theoretical: Discuss opposing theories or models

Step 5: Start writing. This involves writing the introduction, main body and conclusion to sum up the main points, discuss the implications of the literature, and suggest areas for future research.

🪞 Reflection: Think about a real-world problem you've encountered, either personally or in your community. How do you believe incorporating research and insights could have improved the problem statement for that issue? Share your answers on the Padlet below.

Gathering First-Hand Insights

In addition to reviewing existing research, there are times you will need to gather first-hand insights. This involves engaging with key stakeholders, conducting surveys, interviews, or focus groups, and immersing yourself in the real-world context of the problem.

Read Ope's Quest for Literacy Insights

Ope is a Computer Science student in a bustling town in Nigeria. She was deeply concerned about the low literacy levels in her country, particularly among children in underserved communities. She was determined to make a positive impact but knew she needed to gather firsthand insights to truly understand the problem. Ope had to take several steps to gather the required insights.

Step 1 - Identifying the Problem: Ope began her journey by identifying the problem. She researched literacy statistics in Nigeria and learned that a significant number of children struggled with reading and writing. This alarming issue fueled her passion to make a change.

Step 2 - Formulating Questions: To gather firsthand insights, Ope knew she needed to ask the right questions. She reached out to her college professors and mentors for guidance on crafting effective questions that would help her understand the root causes of low literacy rates. She learned the importance of open-ended questions that encouraged people to share their experiences.

Step 3 - Engaging with Stakeholders: Ope realized that she needed to connect with the people directly affected by the issue. She visited a local school in an underserved community where she met with teachers, parents, and students. She engaged them in heartfelt conversations about their experiences with literacy and education.

Step 4 - Observing and Immersing Herself: Understanding the problem required more than just asking questions. Ope spent time observing classrooms, reading sessions, and community events related to education. She immersed herself in the daily lives of those she sought to help.

Step 5 - Recording Findings: Ope diligently recorded her observations, interviews, and conversations. She kept detailed notes, captured photographs, and even recorded some of the heartfelt stories she heard. These records would later serve as valuable insights for her project.

Step 6 - Analyzing and Recognizing Patterns: Back at university, Ope spent hours analyzing her findings. She recognized patterns in the stories she had gathered. It became evident that limited access to reading materials, overcrowded classrooms, and a lack of parental involvement were common themes contributing to low literacy rates.

Step 7 - Seeking Expert Advice: To ensure she was on the right track, Ope sought advice from literacy experts and researchers. They helped her validate her findings and provided valuable perspectives on potential solutions.

Step 8 - Refining Her Problem Statement: Armed with her firsthand insights, Ope was now better equipped to refine her problem statement. She understood the complexities and nuances of the low literacy issue in her country, which would guide her in developing targeted and effective solutions.

Ope's journey to gather firsthand insights was not just an academic pursuit; it was a deeply personal mission. She knew that by understanding the problem from the ground up, she would be better prepared to make a meaningful impact on the lives of those struggling with literacy in her country.

❓ Discussion: What specific steps or strategies employed by Ope do you think are essential when gathering first-hand insights into a social issue, and how can these steps help you better understand and address a problem you care about?

How to Refine Your Problem Statement

Refining your problem statement is a critical phase in the process of addressing a social issue effectively. In the previous subsection, you learned about the importance of gathering research and insights to inform your problem statement. Here, we will delve into the practical strategies and considerations for refining that statement. This phase is where you sharpen the focus, clarity, and relevance of your problem statement, ensuring that it serves as a strong foundation for your subsequent actions and initiatives.

Clarify Your Problem Statement

The first step in refining your problem statement is to clarify it. You've likely gathered a wealth of research and firsthand insights, which may have introduced complexities and multiple perspectives. It's essential to sift through this information and ensure that your problem statement remains concise and clear. Ask yourself:

Is the problem clearly defined? Ensure that the issue you're addressing is explicitly stated.
Have you removed any ambiguities or jargon? Make sure your statement is accessible to a broader audience.
Is the scope well-defined? Clearly specify the boundaries of your problem to prevent it from becoming too broad or unfocused.

📖 Read the following article for more insight on clarifying your problem statement.

To make your problem statement crystal clear, you need to spot the essential ideas in it. Sometimes, when you first describe an issue, you might use words or phrases that leave people scratching their heads. To fix this, check out the main things in your statement - the who or what (subjects), the actions (verbs), and the affected persons or things (objects). Make these words clear by giving them simple explanations. Clear definitions help you when you dive into research. They let you look into existing studies with confidence. Plus, as you read up on your topic, you'll get smart insights that help you fine-tune your research goals and questions. So, finding and defining the big ideas in your initial problem statement is the key to getting things clear and focused.

Incorporate Research Findings

This is the next step in refining your problem statement. The insights and data you've gathered through research play a crucial role in refining your problem statement. Here's how to incorporate research findings effectively:

Highlight relevant research findings: Identify key insights from your research that directly relate to the problem.
Support your problem statement: Use research data and statistics to substantiate the existence and significance of the problem.
Consider contrasting perspectives: Acknowledge different viewpoints or findings from your research that may provide a more comprehensive understanding of the problem.

Address the 'Why'

A refined problem statement should clearly convey why it's essential to address the issue. To do this:

You have to emphasize the significance: Explain why solving this problem matters, both in the short term and long term.
Highlight the consequences: Discuss the potential negative consequences of leaving the problem unaddressed.
Connect to your mission: Relate the problem to your overall mission or goal for addressing the social issue.

🪞 Reflection: Think about a social problem that you are passionate about solving. Why is it important to address this problem? What are the potential consequences of leaving it unaddressed?

Share you thoughts in the padlet below.

Involve Stakeholders

Stakeholder engagement is pivotal in refining your problem statement. Engaging with those directly affected by the problem can provide invaluable input. You can do this in a number of ways:

Collecting stakeholder feedback. This will involve you seeking input from the individuals, communities, or organizations affected by the issue.
Incorporating their perspectives. You can use their collective insights and suggestions to refine and clarify your problem statement.
Ensuring representation. This means striving for diverse representation among stakeholders to capture a comprehensive range of perspectives.

Stay Adaptable and Seek Feedback

Remaining adaptable is vital in refining your problem statement, as it should be able to evolve with changing circumstances. Stay informed about new developments, research updates, and shifting insights related to your problem, and be open to revising your statement to align with the most current understanding of the issue. Keep the lines of communication open with stakeholders, ensuring your problem statement remains relevant and responsive. Seeking feedback from peers, mentors, or experts in your field is equally essential. Their constructive input can be invaluable in refining your problem statement until it resonates effectively with your target audience.

Refining your problem statement is a dynamic and iterative process that requires a combination of clarity, research integration, stakeholder involvement, and adaptability. A well-refined problem statement sets the stage for effective problem-solving initiatives and lays the groundwork for creating positive social impact. In the following sections, we'll explore how to translate your refined problem statement into actionable strategies and projects.

❓ Activity

Problem Statement: ”Many residents of a rural village lack access to clean drinking water, leading to health concerns and a daily struggle for clean water sources.”

Consider the problem statement above and imagine you're a researcher working on a project to tackle the problem of access to clean drinking water in a rural village. You've gathered research findings and insights from the local community.

How would you apply the strategies discussed in this section to refine the problem statement above based on the gathered information? Describe the steps you'd take and the potential impact of this refinement on the project's success.

In conclusion, refining your problem statement is a dynamic and iterative process. It requires a combination of clarity, research integration, stakeholder involvement, and adaptability. A well-refined problem statement sets the stage for effective problem-solving initiatives and lays the groundwork for creating positive social impact.

Course Name